CO129-245 - Acting Governor Fleming - 1890 [5-7] — Page 159

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

06

have the force of older members of tradition among the Public Works Department in Hongkong, orige that they appointed to perform certain duties and work duties. Carnot be expected to assist in the nent outside those of the Department.

My view is that every official of the Department should be prepared to carry out work as directed by the Surveyor General from time to time, provided he is qualified for the performance of the duties required of him. Should the Surveyor General require any official to do anything unreasonable, the matter can at once be referred to His Excellency the Governor, but it is not probable that any official appointed by the Department as Surveyor General would so act.

I am therefore of opinion that for an official to attempt to make conditions as to what duties he shall, and shall not perform is opposed to the first principles of discipline. Mr. Malsch objected to responsibility for field work in connection with land surveys. Now, although the greater part of the field work would necessarily devolve on the Assistant Land Surveyor, it is clearly the duty of the Officer in charge of the Land Survey to satisfy himself of the accuracy of the work done, and in case of need, i.e., should the work fall in arrears, or the Assistant Land Surveyor be invalided, it would be necessary for Mr. Maloch to undertake the field work.

As regards the question of the appointment of Assistant Surveyor General, I submit that the Surveyor General should be in a better position than any subordinate Official of the Department to recommend the official best qualified to fill that post.

As the transfer of Mr. Bowdler from the appointment of Assistant Surveyor General to that of "Special Engineer" to...

Edit History

2026-05-26 03:58:48 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
06 have the force of older members of tradition among the Public Works Department in Hongkong, orige that they appointed to perform certain duties and work duties. Carnot be expected to assist in the nent outside those of the Department. My view is that every official of the Department should be prepared to carry out work as directed by the Surveyor General from time to time, provided he is qualified for the performance of the duties required of him. Should the Surveyor General require any official to do anything unreasonable, the matter can at once be referred to His Excellency the Governor, but it is not probable that any official appointed by the Department as Surveyor General would so act. I am therefore of opinion that for an official to attempt to make conditions as to what duties he shall, and shall not perform is opposed to the first principles of discipline. Mr. Malsch objected to responsibility for field work in connection with land surveys. Now, although the greater part of the field work would necessarily devolve on the Assistant Land Surveyor, it is clearly the duty of the Officer in charge of the Land Survey to satisfy himself of the accuracy of the work done, and in case of need, i.e., should the work fall in arrears, or the Assistant Land Surveyor be invalided, it would be necessary for Mr. Maloch to undertake the field work. As regards the question of the appointment of Assistant Surveyor General, I submit that the Surveyor General should be in a better position than any subordinate Official of the Department to recommend the official best qualified to fill that post. As the transfer of Mr. Bowdler from the appointment of Assistant Surveyor General to that of "Special Engineer" to...
Baseline (Original)
06 have the force of a older members of tradition among. the Public Worke the Department in Hongkong, orige that they appointed to perform certain duties and work duties. Carnot be expected: to assist in the nent outside those of the Departmen My view is that every official of the Department should be prepared out onok work as to the Surveyor General carry way from time to time direct, provided he is qualified for the performance of the duties required of him. Should the Surveyor General require any official to anything do unreasonable the matter can at once be referred to His Excellency the Governor, but it is not probable that any official appointed by the Deanetary Itate as Surveyor I am of Wate so act. Qu Ap General would therefore of spinion that for official to attempt to make conditions to what duties he shall, and shall not perform is opposed to the first. principles of discipline. Mr Malsch objeck 156 ld work object to responsibility for field in convection with land surveys. Now, although beast greater part at as a rule, the : work would necessarity of the field. devolve on the Avvistant Land Surveyor it is clearly the duty of the Offiennes the Land Survey locating y charge of hunnelf of the accuracy of done, and in case satisfy the field work of need, i. e. should fall in arrean, or the Assistant the work fall in Land Surveyor be invalided, it would be neccesary for take the Mr. Maloch to under_ field work. "As regrends the question of the appointment of Assistant Surveyor I submit that the surveyor General, General should be in better position than any a subordinate Official of Department to MI Con the mmend the official best qualified to fill that post. As the transfer of Mr. Bowdler. from the appointment of Asistant Surveyor General to that of "Special Enginar " to the
2026-05-26 03:58:48 · Baseline
View content

06

have the force of a older members of

tradition

among.

the Public Worke

the

Department in Hongkong, orige that they appointed to perform certain duties

and

work

duties.

Carnot

be

expected:

to assist in the

nent outside those

of the Departmen

My

view is that every official of

the Department should be prepared

out onok work as

to

the Surveyor General carry way from time to time direct, provided he is qualified for the performance of the duties required of him. Should the Surveyor General require any official to

anything

do

unreasonable the matter

can at once be

referred

to His Excellency

the Governor, but it is not probable that any official appointed by the Deanetary

Itate as Surveyor I am

of Wate

so act.

Qu

Ap

General

would

therefore of spinion that for official to attempt to make conditions

to what duties he shall, and shall

not perform is opposed to the first. principles of discipline. Mr Malsch

objeck

156

ld work

object to responsibility for field

in convection with land surveys. Now,

although

beast

greater part

at

as a rule, the

: work would necessarity

of the field.

devolve on the Avvistant Land Surveyor

it is clearly the duty of the Offiennes

the Land Survey locating y

charge of

hunnelf of the accuracy of

done, and in case

satisfy

the field

work

of need, i. e. should

fall in arrean, or the Assistant

the work fall in

Land Surveyor be invalided, it would

be neccesary for

take the

Mr. Maloch to under_

field work.

"As regrends the question of the

appointment of Assistant Surveyor

I submit that the surveyor

General,

General should be in better position

than

any

a

subordinate Official of

Department to

MI Con

the

mmend the

official

best qualified to fill that post.

As the transfer of

Mr. Bowdler.

from the appointment of Asistant Surveyor General to that of "Special Enginar " to

the

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.